Tiger-Man #1. Somehow I'm not feeling awe. |
Years later, I was shocked to discover those comics had had nothing but opprobrium heaped on them from all sources.
Could it be true? Could these mags I remembered so fondly - with titles like The Tarantula, Iron-Jaw and Devilina - really deserve all this contempt?
Sadly, I had to wait until the wonders of the Internet allowed me to rebuild my collection to find out.
Even more sadly, that contempt really was deserved. Every single Atlas Comic I've re-acquired over the last few years has been awful (although The Phoenix had potential even if it was never tapped). And here, as further evidence, we have Tiger-Man.
I'd love to say Tiger-Man #1 is a triumph that proves the critics to be fools but it's simply dreadful. A doctor in Africa injects himself with tiger serum, in order to... ...well, in order to inject himself with tiger serum, and promptly gains the powers of a tiger. Why his origin's set in Africa and not Asia if he gains the powers of a tiger is anybody's guess but, regardless, he returns to New York where his sister's promptly murdered.
Tiger-Man, a hero so awesome his feet can't be contained by a mere comic book panel. Hold on a minute, aren't his arms and legs blue in the rest of the story? |
Ignoring the fact he now looks a complete plonker, Tiger-Man tracks down the killers and kills them. So, basically, it's a new kind of hero - a murderer.
All this might not matter if our hero had anything that even vaguely resembles a personality but he's such a complete and total block of wood that you half-expect Handy Andy to start sawing him in half at any point. It says it all about writer Gabriel Levy's lack of interest in character development that we're nine pages into a twenty page story before we even get to find out the hero's first name.
But Atlas Comics, so many talented and experienced people involved. How did it all go so disastrously wrong?
HA! I felt the exact same way when I saw that cover the first time. Phenomenally underwhelming. Tigers in Africa....
ReplyDeletePoor old Tiger-Man.
ReplyDeleteBad compared to what? Certainly they compare favorably to anything Marvel or DC were publishing at the time. They also paid the hired hands a lot better by all accounts. It's a shame Martin Goodman interfered at issue 3 across the board and didn't let the potential be realized.
ReplyDeleteNo, they don't compare favorably.
DeleteLoved them then. Love them still. Something wrong with you. :)
ReplyDeleteAs long as they're still giving someone pleasure, I'm happy, Steve.
ReplyDeleteAlso your headline misquotes, there is no "well" at the end of the line, it's "Alas, poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio."
ReplyDeleteYou are indeed, correct, Matt.
ReplyDeleteIt's such a shame. Atlas was such a potentially exciting venture but, somehow, all that potential was wasted.
ReplyDeleteI loved pretty much all of the titles ...... Tiger Man was kinda their least interesting character ....... Planet of Vampires was pretty awesome !! .... Grim Ghost was also a very interesting character as was Moorlock .... Demon Hunter was also a great character ....These Atlas comics very simply DO NOT deserve the contempt they have been given by so many internet shmucks who think they know comics .... do they compare to the comics that are printed today in 2020 ? no they do not .... but these Atlas comics are comparable to , if not superior to much of what Marvel and DC were pumping out at the time these Atlas comics were being published ....... certainly superior to anything Charlton or Gold Key produced .... its sad that Atlas fizzled out before it could really get going .... if you know a little of the history .... it was Marvel and DC who crushed them by filling comic racks with tons of their titles and pushing these Atlas titles out of sight ..... Some of these titles are still viable .... Planet of Vampires could very easily be the next "Walking Dead" type T.V. series
ReplyDelete