Sunday 30 October 2022

Mega-Halloween Special Collector's Edition Post. Your favourite Horror comics.

Thanks to Charlie Horse 47 and Killdumpster for their sponsorship of this post, via the magic of Patreon
***

The Many Ghosts of Dr Graves #45, Tom Sutton
G
reetings, my fellow traveller in the Darkest Realms of the Human Soul. Has there ever, in the entire history of humanity, been a genre worse suited to comics than that of horror?

All wise readers cherish it, hugging it to their bosom, like the teddy bear they were once inseparable from but, bearing in mind that the British and American comic book has traditionally been aimed at children - and there is, by law, a limit to what you may inflict upon those of an immature leaning - launching a horror comic is, it seems, an act of madness itself.

But then again, could we truly expect horror comics to be frightening, even when aimed at adults?

After all, if we peruse Hollywood, its horror output is routinely aimed at adults and, having studied the form for lo these many decades, I always insist the only film of that genre I've ever encountered which is capable of eliciting a sense of dread in even the timidest of viewer is Trilogy of Terror. And, even then, only when one is twelve years old.

Still, despite the limitations placed upon them by the authorities, the big publishers of our youth all produced comics in that genre.

While DC largely concentrated upon the production of similarly-styled anthologies such as Weird War Tales, The Unexpected, The Witching Hour and the Houses of Mystery and Secrets, not to mention a Forbidden Mansion, Marvel settled its gaze upon transforming horror stars into defacto super-heroes, thanks to the likes of The Son of Satan, Ghost Rider, Werewolf by Night and the Monster of Frankenstein engaging in often feeble battles with the forces of malice. Why, even that scoundrel Dracula managed to battle evil in his Marvel days, despite being, himself, always more evil than the evil he was fighting.

Charlton in the 1970s seemed to barely supply us with anything but horror tales. Who can forget the thrills of The Many Ghosts of Dr Graves, Ghost Manor, Haunted and Ghostly Haunts?

Then again, for those with more grown-up tastes, Warren gave us Vampirella, Eerie and Creepy.

In its brief existence, Atlas Seaboard bequeathed upon us Devilina and Tales of Evil - books which bore no detectable resemblance to any ever produced by other companies.

But there was, before even any of that, the legendary venture known as EC whose titles were so extreme that the Comics Code had to be invented in order to reassure reader's mothers that, from now on, the horror comics their children read would be as devoid of horror as was humanly possible.

But choices must be made. And I am, thus, going to have to announce that Weird War Tales was my favourite of DC's horror titles. Perhaps it was its range of exotic artists, perhaps it was merely the indefatigable parade of skeletons which adorned its covers but the book managed to make even I enjoy war stories, despite my habitual antipathy towards the field.

Meanwhile, for my love of the Son of Satan's first two adventures, Tomb of Dracula was the Marvel horror book that most often drew my gaze towards the spinner racks.

Midnight Tales, however, was my Charlton supernatural epic of choice, with its host Professor Coffin, his theoretically beautiful niece Arachne, and its tongue embedded firmly within its cheek.

Tragically, the only Atlas Seaboard horror book I ever read was issue #1 of Tales of Evil. Therefore, in the absence of any competition, I must, perforce, nominate that as my favourite from that company.

As far as I can recall, the only Warren book I ever read was issue #30 of Vampirella which I remember mostly for a magnificently coloured strip by Richard Corben. Thus, I must select that as my favoured Warren book.

The only one of Skywald's horror offerings that I ever read was Nightmare #17. Frankly, it was not to my tastes, featuring the eating of human flesh far too often for a man of my distinction to appreciate. But it did feature a woman being turned into a naked bee queen, which is a thing that appealed to me greatly.

Despite their decades of notoriety, I must confess to never having read any EC comics. I cannot, therefore, nominate a top pick from that bunch.

Nor, as far as I'm aware, did I ever read an issue of Misty, Fleetway's legendary late-1970s horror anthology for girls. I do feel as though I should, though, in the interests of filling the gaps within my knowledge.

There was also, of course, Dez Skinn's House of Hammer, the only issue of which I ever encountered being that which adapted the cinematic delight Twins of Evil. That must, therefore, be my favourite from the series.

But what of you? Which horror comics have most readily floated your boat across the River Styx? You are, as always, free to expand upon the subject, below. 

That is, provided the chill hand of fear does not prevent you moving your pen across the paper.

And, while you're at it, feel free to share any thoughts you may have upon the subject of Halloween. My first memory of it is of wandering around a back garden, sometime in the late 1960s, armed with a blazing turnip and a sense of northernness, thus sinking the myth that Halloween did not exist in England until ten years ago. I remember thinking at the time, "Look at me! Here I am, deft master of horror, in the late 1960s, sinking the myth that Halloween did not exist in England before 2012!"

31 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm not a big horror guy, but...

These are favourites, not necessarily through horror, but because they were part of my childhood:

1.) Secrets of Haunted House # 12 - horror Hamlet spoof my brother bought at a school sale.

2.) SS & CB # 237 - CB vs a werewolf - I bought it at a school sale.

3.) Moon Knight vs Lupinar (stuff about lycanthropy/the hirsute disease seemed cool to young me.)

4.) Creepshow comic/magazine 1982 - gift from American great cousin/auntie (?), now passed.

5.) Couple of Perlin/Budiansky Ghost Riders - chimed with my age.

6.)Blade in Savage Action - Blade thinks he's killed a girl, by mistake.

Anyone noticed how fears change, with age? As a kid (aged 9?), I found the Buck Rogers Space vampires scary. When the show repeated, years later, I found them laughable!

Phillip

Charlie Horse 47 said...

King Charlie isn't big into horror either and wonders about the psychological profile of those who are. That said...

Charlie has read the various EC horror lines. "Mister you forgot your club" is classic, lol. EC had compelling stories and were the only horror comics Charlie purposely read.

Charlie also purposely bought many a Weird War Tales but never really thought of them as horror comics.

Perhaps the most profound horror comic, were one to call it that, Charlie has read is The Divine Comedy by Dante as illustrated by Gustav Dori. It shakes Charlie enough to say his prayers, lol.

Redartz said...

Ah, a perfect topic for a dark, clammy, rainy evening-before-Halloween.

When I was young, horror didn't grab me much. But now I find it most enjoyable, picking up the odd book here and there. Usually pretty cheaply- one often finds such comics in bulk lots at yard sales and flea markets; guess many folks figure they aren't worth much due to the absence of superhero types...

As for favorites : many of DC's early 70's anthologies, with frequently great art by the likes of Adams and Wrightson, Gray Morrow, Alex Toth and Sergio Aragones.

From Marvel- I always loved Man-Thing; of course those stories were generally less about the creature than about the surrounding cast of characters. Nevertheless, there were some genuinely creepy tales: particularly issues 5 and 6, "Night of the Laughing Dead".

Archie had some nice stories in "Chilling Adventures in Sorcery ". The first two issues had the unusual sight of 'horror' art by Stan Goldberg and Dan Decarlo. The second series, under the Red Circle label, had some sharp work by the previously mentioned Gray Morrow.

Redartz said...

Oh wow, I neglected the second part of Steve's question! My earliest Halloween memory is parading around school in my Casper the Friendly Ghost costume as a wide-eyed 5 year old. A few short years later it was a fine night of Trick-or-treating with friends, a precious sack of candy held firmly in my grip. One year , must have been about 1970- we went to one house. A teenaged girl answered and invited us in. The room was full of hippie types, complete with lava lamps, rock music and an odd haze in the air. They were nice and gave us candy, but it was a pretty strange sight to a small town Indiana kid...

Charlie Horse 47 said...

Charlie's earliest Hollywood memories were of wearing a Lone Ranger mask. Eventually Charlie worked his way up to a Spider Man outfit.

But Halloween was all about the candy. Nothing else. No one thought about scaring anyone.

Well... a little bit of vandalism too, lol. Charlie remembers his younger brother swiping some eggs, which turned out to be hard boiled, from the fridge and shattering a neighbors front room window. Man did we run!

Charlie Horse 47 said...

PHILLIP - Charlie dug out DD #93 from the long boxes to prep for your upcoming review, lol.

I must say that I think you have your hands full! Lots going in that issue!

Anonymous said...

The only horror comic I read over an extended period was Swamp Thing. While there were plenty of gross moments (Halo of Flies stings to mind) I think the most actually horrific moment, for me, was in #48 'Murder of Crows' when the Brujeria transform Judith into a crow. She vomits away her body and realise only her head remains. This issue was pencilled and inked by Totleben (as the best issues generally were) and he captured the horror on her face once she realised what she had agreed to. Genuinely horrific.

The scene where the Invunche pushes Emma out if the high-rise window, in #37, and Constantine's various crew all have seizures, probably runs a close second. All part of the same storyline Brrr...

DW

Anonymous said...

Seems like I’m the Designated Weirdo of the gang, that actually loves Horror Comics. As such, it’s hard for me to narrow down individual ‘favorites’, but I’ll give it a try.

Warren: pound for pound, CREEPY was probably their ‘best’ title overall but I have a soft spot for EERIE. My Desert Island Pick: EERIE 60.

DC: Too many individual stories from their many anthologies to choose just one. Guess I could just go with SAGA OF THE SWAMP THING 21 (‘The Anatomy Lesson’).

Marvel: TOMB OF DRACULA was their most consistently excellent ongoing series, but I’m going with WEREWOLF BY NIGHT 10 as my Desert Island Pick, purely for Tom Sutton’s outstanding artwork.

Atlas / Seaboard: TALES OF EVIL 2 with a nice 9-page werewolf story by Sutton.

Charlton: GHOST MANOR 9, with yet another groovy werewolf yarn by Sutton.

Archie: CHILLING ADVENTURES IN SORCERY 3, with 5 stories by Gray Morrow.

Skywald: PSYCHO 3, featuring the first chapter of Tom Sutton’s utterly bonkers ‘Frankenstein Book II’ series.

Pacific : TWISTED TALES 5

EC : gonna have to give this one some thought.

b.t.

Anonymous said...

I've enjoyed the discussion! These are worthy all entries. I remember Eerie (Yikes). And in my dark and haunted soul, I carry fond memories of Charlton Comics.

...Wait. did I say "fond memories"?
I meant to say EVIL memories. HAHAHAHAHA
I remember one story, I think Ditko drew it, where a thief gets trapped in a mausoleum with the ghost of the old dead rich guy he was trying to rob. Like, forever. As I said earlier, yikes!

But seriously, I did enjoy those comics as a kid. Still do, on occasion! I love the idea of a "horror host" or master of ceremonies, as it were. Winnie the Witch was my favorite!

As far as who wrote the scariest comics, I'd have to say Alan Moore. "The Brimstone Ballet" was truly terrifying.
The problem was, in terms of horror, where does a writer go from there? I dunno.
But sure enough, Anton Arcane would return, from a place nobody's supposed to be able to return from. Like I said, scary.

Happy Halloween, all!

M.P.

Anonymous said...

Redartz - I'd forgotten about 'Night of the Laughing Dead' - that definitely deserves a mention!

Charlie - As regards DD # 93, I finished it in a rush, expecting SDC to change to '50 years ago', then - lo & behold - SDC's a Hallowe'en special (the pressure's off!) Still, without a deadline, I'd never have got motivated to write anything!

Phillip

Anonymous said...

I suppose, as a kid, a lot of horror is lighthearted/humorous.

Anyone else get 'Monster Fun' & 'Shiver & Shake' annuals, as a kid?

http://www.tonystrading.co.uk/galleries/annuals/monsterfun.htm

http://www.tonystrading.co.uk/galleries/annuals/shiverandshake.htm

I got MF for 1978 & 1979, and S&S 1979, I think!

Phillip

Redartz said...

Ok, here's another great favorite. Bongo Comics, for years (until they folded a couple years ago) published an annual edition of "Simpsons' Treehouse of Horror ". The format was basically like that of the tv show- if you haven't seen it, this Halloween episode usually consists of three short animated horror/comic tales. Often the subject matter is pop culture referential. For instance, one great episode parodied "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown "...
Anyway, issue 11 of the Bongo comic version parodied classics from the world of comics. It was a 'flip book', you have to turn the book upside down and backwards to read both halves. One side had parodies of "Tomb of Dracula " by Marv Wolfman and Gene Colan, and a lampoon of "Swamp Thing " by Len Wein and Bernie Wrightson.
The other side skewered EC Comics, with stories by Angelo Torres, John Severin and Al Williamson.
A terrific book, well worth grabbing if you find it...

Anonymous said...

Ken Reid's 'Frankie Stein' and Leo Baxendale's 'Grimly Feendish' are classics Philip.
Out of interest, do you also mark Samhain with a blazing turnip of northernness?

Steve, obviously - and perhaps predictably coming from me - the greatest horror comic ever is 'From Hell' by Alan Moore and Eddie Campbell. And my fave anthology would be its first home, Steve Bissette and John Totleben's Taboo (which was also the first place I read Alejandro Jodorowsky and Moebius' 'Eyes of the Cat/Les Yeux du Chat').

Also, Alan Moore's recent 'Neonomicon' and 'Providence' are great too (even if Jacen Burroughs artwork isn't always to my taste). The first in particular was somewhat controversial at the time - a horror comic thats horrible, imagine that.

I agree with Matthew about the amazing Richard Corben's later work - he drew the best run of Hellbazer since the Jamie Delano era, 'Hard Time'. Although I rate his earlier stuff too - 'Beast of Wolfton', 'Rowlf' etc - and in fact that whole era of underground comics he came out of.
Slow Death, Skull, Death Rattle... and the fantastic one-off Legion of Charlies by Tom Veitch and Greg Irons.

The other great late career flourish by an artist was Barry Windsor-Smith's recent 'Monsters'.
Somewhat surprising no-one's bought up other former Studio artist the mighty Berni Wrightson, unless you count Philip mentioning Creepshow, and he was in Eerie #60 (Wrightson that is, not Phillip)
Come on b.t. - the best Pacific horror comic was Berni Wrightson Master of the Macabre, which reprinted a load of his amazing Warren stuff like 'Muck Monster' and the delightful 'Jennifer'...

-sean

Anonymous said...

Sean - Since October started, from my window, I've watched the farm down the road do a roaring trade, selling pumpkins at exorbitant prices, to thousands of gullible punters. So, after 4 weeks, I'm sick of the sight of pumpkins, by now - turnips would make a change! What if the Green Goblin threw turnip bombs at Spidey?

Phillip

Anonymous said...

I couldn't say Phillip - Spidey is more dangermash's department.

Steve, Misty is worth checking out. Like the other IPC comics of the era its a bit of a mixed bag, but Rebellion have been reprinting some of the better stories like Pat Mills' 'Moonchild' - think Carrie, but set in Grange Hill - and 'The Sentinels' by Malcolm Shaw (who's perhaps best remembered for 'Return to Armageddon' in 2000AD) about an empty tower block that formed a gateway to an alternate Nazi Britain.

https://www.greatnewsforallreaders.com/blog/2016/1/31/on-this-day-4-february-1978-misty

Its worth mentioning the similarly witchy and gothy Spellbound comic - also dominated by Spanish artists - that came out a couple of years earlier from DC Thompson, sort of like the Warlord to Misty's Battle if you see what I mean.

https://jintycomic.wordpress.com/2018/08/20/spellbound-no-1-25-september-1976/

-sean

Anonymous said...

Sean: I didn’t mention Wrightson by name, but yes, he does indeed have a gorgeously illustrated story in EERIE 60, one of my Desert Island Picks. There’s a nice full-color Corben story in that issue too. Afraid I’ll have to disagree about Pacific’s BERNI WRIGHTSON, MASTER OF THE MACABRE series. Great collection of stories, yes, but all of em colored horribly. The astounding ‘Jenifer’ must be seen in its original black and white.

Two more: GHOST STORIES 1 from Dell, featuring odd, surreal, nightmarish stories by John Stanley (the Little Lulu guy). There’s also a similar one-shot he wrote for Dell called TALES FROM THE TOMB. It’s great too but GHOST STORIES has the horrifying ‘Monster From Dread End’ so it’s my fave of the two. Scans of both issues are out there on the internets, so check em out….if you DARE…

b.t.

Anonymous said...

Oops, Redartz mentioned the Bern - sorry Red, you got in there just before me there so I missed your comment. I did enjoy Bongo's Radioactive Man - Who Washes the Washmen Infinite Secrets of Legendary Crossover Knight Wars ("Oops, I dropped my badge") - so I'll keep an eye out for Treehouse of Horror.

Also - no love for Mike Mignola's Hellboy round these parts?

-sean

-

Anonymous said...

b.t., The Pacific Wrighson reprints would certainly have been better going with the original black and white, but they weren't terrible ('Muck Monster' was more subtly done than the Warren colour version imo).
Although thats a fair point on Jennifer', which is an exception because of how it was drawn using ink washes.

-sean

Anonymous said...

You know whats also better in black and white b.t.? Jim Steranko's 'Stroke of Midnight', which I first read in the Marvel Superheroes And The Occult Winter Special UK one-shot from 1980.
It also included that Dr Doom story about his annual battle for his mother's soul, drawn by Gene Colan and Tom Palmer from Astonishing Tales #8. Nice.

-sean

Anonymous said...

Sean - I read Astonishing Tales # 8 much later, in Essential Super-villain team-up. Doom & his mother's soul's a bit like Kang & Ravonna (unobtainable/in suspended animation). Not to mention both villains' interest in time travel!

Phillip

Matthew McKinnon said...

I kind of like Hellboy but I tuned out some time ago.

I picked up the issues Corben did, but they didn’t tempt me back onboard. It’s a bit of the Sin City Syndrome*: a single story or series pretty much sums it up. It’s all very much the same and gets a bit stale after a while. The films didn’t help, either.

*I should add that I like Hellboy A LOT more than Sin City.

McSCOTTY said...

Sean, Excellent mention of Ken Reid kids comics work. His " Frankie Stein " and " The Nerves " we're funny but at times borderline horrific. I also like Mignola's Hellboy and especially B.P.R.D which I still pick up now and then. But the only strip I found genuine!y horrific was Tom Sutton Morbius from Vampire Tales issue 7 where there is a hanging - that page is on my blog of interested.

https://twthen.blogspot.com/2022/10/bring-on-back-ups-vampire-tales-issue-9.html


My favourite horror mystery comic at the time was DCs Witching Hour .I also liked
Corbens stuff and those early issues of Warrens Creepy mag.

My first Halloween memory was as a kid of about 7 years old when at school we were read "Tam O'Shanter "by Rabbie Burns ( for non Brits a legendary Scottish poet) and then going out "guising" ( dressing in a " disguise") when you would do a joke, song or poem for for sweets . I remember being so embarrassed trying to sing " Ally Bally" a Scots kids folk song. We didn't do trick or treat them just a song etc for sweets before the American version took over..

Anonymous said...

Sean

Have you seen the coloured version of From Hell? I've got it but haven't done a re-read yet. I always thought of it as a physcological crime drama rather than horror. Not that there's much difference, thinking about it.

DW

Anonymous said...

No, I've not read the colour version of From Hell yet DW.
Not that I have any objection on principle or anything, I've just not got round to it yet. Apparently Eddie Campbell corrected some of the artwork too - I read a recent interview where he said that since the original work its become much easier to research the subject visually (thanks to Google) and he took advantage of that to make backgrounds and stuff more accurate.

As to whether From Hell is horror (or Horror)... well, I suppose you could ask if its really in any genre? I mean, what other books are there like it?
Just as well I didn't mention Miracleman then (;
Hey, #15 was pretty horrific, and you can see the whole of the Moore run as a version of the Frankenstein myth...

Any thoughts on his Lovecraft stuff, like Providence?

-sean

Anonymous said...

I haven't read any of the Lovecraft stuff. It's not really my cup of tea and i was turned off by the art. Eddie did spend a lot of time colourising (his term) the art and he did fix (again, his term) quite a bit. I fancied a re-read, anyway, and picked up the coloured collected edition (my fifth version) but haven't yet got to it. I used to love horror movies/book/comics/tv as a youngster but I've gone soft in my (relatively) old age.

DW

Anonymous said...

I'm not that keen on Burrow's artwork either DW, or that much into Lovecraft.
Even so, Neonomicon and especially Providence are still... well, 'enjoyable' maybe isn't really the right word, as they make the racism and misogyny hidden in Lovecraft's work the subject, but they're worth a read.

-sean

Matthew McKinnon said...

I’ll second that. One of the major disappointments in Alan Moore’s late comics work is that he didn’t have better artists (obviously not including Kev O’Neill in that though I feel his stuff has skewed towards cartooning rather than illustration lately).

Given one of the joys of his work was that he could coax astonishing artwork out of unexpected artists by playing to their strengths - Dave Gibbons wasn’t universally lauded prior to Watchmen, I remember him being seen as an unexceptional safe pair of hands in the 80s - I don’t know why people weren’t queuing out the door to collaborate. Is Burrows really the best artist on the books?

The Providence take on ‘Shadow Over Innsmouth’ is devastating.

Anonymous said...


Re: EC…

Almost impossible to pick just one comic or story, but HAUNT OF FEAR 24 is ‘a’ favorite. Highlight of the issue is ‘Drink To Me Only With Thine Eyes’ by Otto Binder and Graham Ingels. A woman and her lover kill her husband and dissolve his body in lye — hubby comes back to life as a sentient blob of gooey flesh to exact his revenge. It’s wonderfully yucky. Ingels’ blobby Silly Putty Monster was clearly the visual inspiration for Wrightson’s Lovecraftian horror M’Naghalah in SWAMP THING 8.

b.t.

Anonymous said...

Matthew, Moore originally wrote Neonomicon fairly quickly in response to an open offer from Avatar to do anything for them because he needed the money - pretty sure Burrows was their choice. Probably for Providence too, later (and of course Moore tends to stick with the same artist on a series if he can).

No doubt plenty of artists are up for collaborating with him - pretty much everyone available who was anyone did at least a guest spot on his ABC stuff - but of course he tends to not work for Marvel or DC, and his more involved stuff does demand a fair bit of commitment.

I actually like the fact that he's willing to work with new artists that aren't big names. Although I preferred Gabriel Andrade to Burrows... have you read Crossed +100? Interesting to see Moore do some work on a 'genre' comic quite late in his career, created by someone else...

-sean

Matthew McKinnon said...

Yeah, coincidentally I’m re-reading Crossed + 100 now. I got it when it came out and wasn’t all that keen. But I thought I’d give it another go when I found it in a box in the loft. The art is… serviceable, I guess?

Anonymous said...

Serviceable - thats the word I was looking for. Yeah, Andrade is a bit more serviceable than Burrows, so while it would be nice to have someone better, being deeply average isn't er... the end of the world.

-sean