Sunday, 30 August 2026

Phantom Stranger #41. Will the Real Black Orchid Please Stand Up?

Thanks to Charlie Horse 47 and Killdumpster for their sponsorship of this post, via the magic of Patreon
***

Phantom Stranger #41, Will the Real Black Orchid please stand up?
Those with keen memories will know that, just three months ago, I took a look at the last issue of the Bronze Age run of the Phantom Stranger's legendary comic.

But the fedora-flaunting downfall of fools and fiends wasn't the only star of that book, as there was also a backup strip. One that starred none other than the Black Orchid.

Or perhaps I should say it starred a whole gang of Black Orchids.

For in the mag's previous issue, heiress and Black Orchid fan Ronne Kuhn had been invited to join a secret society composed entirely of Black Orchids!

Yes, it was true. In a shocking development, there was never one Orchid. There were a whole bunch of them who worked together to fight crime. And so impressed by Ronne were they that they invited her to become a member of their team.

Phantom Stranger #41, Deadman, final issue
But it turned out she'd been duped. They weren't Black Orchids at all. They were a gang of criminals and had hoodwinked her into helping them commit their latest heist, the robbery of a bank vault!

Holey Moley!

Now, at the start of this month's instalment, they've tied her to that vault's door, along with a bomb that's all set to blow it - and her - to kingdom come!

Is it curtains for the woman dressed as a woman whose costume seems to have been made from curtains?

No, it isn't because, just as all seems lost, the real Black Orchid appears, tears the vault door off its hinges, with her bare hands and flings it into the sky where it won't do any harm to anyone apart from anyone stood beneath it when it showers a rain of deadly chunks of metal down on them.

Phantom Stranger #41, the Black Orchid, Ronnie Kuhn, queen of the fire hose
That menace dealt with, the Orchid and Ronne quickly set about rounding up the wrongdoers, with Ronne capturing their ringleader Karen, via the judicious use of a fire hose.

Of course, job done, the Orchid disappears, as she always does, leaving Ronne to deal with the police who are convinced she's the real Black Orchid.

It has to be said it's a very simple episode, reminiscent of the Golden Age days of heroes who'd simply burst in and give the villains a good leathering with no difficulty at all. But, then, it never was a strip that had you worried about the survival chances of its heroine.

However, it's interesting to see the Orchid make reference to Batman, Robin and even the Justice League, even though I've always been under the impression that, like the 1970s Spectre stories, the idea behind the strip is that it takes place in a world in which super-heroes - apart from the protagonist - don't exist. I can only put this down to writer Michael Fleisher and his legendary continuity adviser Russell Carley possibly forgetting this.

Phantom Stranger #41, the Black Orchid
Then again, I could just have always been wrong and maybe it is set on a world in which super-heroes exist.

Regardless, I approve of it being set in a world in which super-heroes exist.

And we should be honest about it, writing is for wimps. The appeal of the strip was always its art and it has to be said that this issue's penciller Fred Carrillo is no Nestor Redondo but he does, at least, give us a style that's in the same ballpark.

And so it's all over for the heroine and, as the book hits cancellation, she, for now, departs our lives, as big a mystery as she was when first she appeared. Was she a scientist? Was she a supernatural being? Was she - given the nature of her various powers - Supergirl in disguise?

It looks like, unless some fool brings her back and gives her an origin story, we shall never find out.

Just as long as she doesn't turn out to be a human/plant hybrid.

I don't think I'd ever get over that.

Phantom Stranger #41, Black Orchid for a while

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

Byrne criticized DC for "de-uniquing" characters. Here, multiple Black Orchids (albeit fake! ), and Supergirl in disguise as a possibility too? Is a black orchid a rare, and unusual flower, or not? ( Nice article, Steve, by the way! )
Phillip

Matthew McKinnon said...

Pink Lycra with black frilly undies over the top. Grim.

Anonymous said...

MM - I am with you on the kooky kostume bottoms.

And why isn’t Black Orchid sporting a black uniform? Charlie could almost believe some schmoo at DC was ogling Marvel’s original version of Black Widow who started out in purple when DC’s BO was created.

dangermash said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
dangermash said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
dangermash said...

Is it?

** Makes same face as David Brent after being caught out pretending to fire Finchy over the phone while talking to the speaking clock. **

Third time lucky. Apparently if you put diamond brackets around part of a comment, the brackets and whatever's inside them end up not showing up.

Anonymous said...

Btw - I did very much enjoy the write-up Steve! JP

Anonymous said...

Yes, excellent post, Steve. And “fedora-flaunting downfall of fools and fiends”…top marks :)

b.t.

Anonymous said...

b.t. - Remove, or put brackets around, 'down' - and the alliteration's even more sustained, and uninterrupted! Or does 'down' improve the rhythm a bit, giving it a bit of 'bounce' ? Yes, I think it does!

Phillip

Anonymous said...

I kinda wondered what her deal was. But some things are not meant to be known.
Any origin story they cook up is bound to be pretty ridiculous.

Apropos of nothing, did you guys catch the lunar eclipse?
Majestic in it's way.
To quote Leonard Nimoy, "The cosmic ballet...goes on."
M.P.

Colin Jones said...

The drought is officially over - I've seen more rain in the last three days than in the previous three months!

Colin Jones said...

Radio 4 has just broadcast an excellent two-part adaptation of 'Midnight Cowboy' (August 23rd and 30th). I wasn't sure if I'd seen the film version or not but I recognised the ending when it came so I must have seen the film after all.

Anonymous said...

M.P. - On this side of the pond, the eclipse was at 5am - or something - so I slept through it! Brings to mind "An Eclipse, Waning" - that classic Moon Knight tale, introducing the character, to many UK readers, with excellent faux-Neal Adams art, inked by Bob McLeod. Moon Knight's strength decreased, the eclipse waning (so, a powers-establishing tale, of sorts). However, clobbered by the Hulk in the dark, whether ghostly Moon Knight's
strength was waxing or waning, wouldn't have matter one iota! A great art story, regardless!

Phillip

Anonymous said...

"mattered" ! Damn typos!

Phillip

Anonymous said...

COLIN!

Well, to me Midnight Cowboy is about “EVERYBODY’s TALKIN at ME.”

Harry Nilssen (Schmillson)

By 2026, he is a forgotten musical artist and composer of the 1960s mostly.

Yet we all know “Put the LIME in the COCONUT ” and “Everybody’s Talkin.”

And I suspect at least in america we all recall (maybe vaguely) “ME AND MY ARROW.” It featured in the dodge arrow car commercial but was actually the theme to an animated film that ive never seen nor can recall the name of. But Me and My Arrow is a really weird ear worm.

As a side note, both Lennon and McCartney stated he was their favorite American composer. All the Beatles were tight with him.

And when the chips were down, and RCA wanted to cancel Harry’s musical contract, Lennon told RCA that if they resigned Harry, John and Ringo would then sign with RCA. RCA resigned Harry. But they didnt get John or Ringo LOL

Anonymous said...

MP - yesterday, I did play DARK SIDE OF THE MOON in lieu of seeing the eclipse. (One thought leads to another!) Vinyl that i bought around 1977, natch!

Colin Jones said...

JP, I heard 'Everybody's Talkin' At Me' in my local Tesco just a few months ago - what a lovely song!

'Without You' is another big hit by Harry Nilsson - it reached No.1 in the UK in 1971 and then it reached No.1 again in 1994 sung by Mariah Carey.

Anonymous said...

Good call COLIN! For decades I thought WITHOUT YOU was a Gilbert O’Sullivan tune (Alone Again Naturally, Claire). Forgive me all!

Nilsson Schmilsson Forever!

McSCOTTY said...

"Without you was first recorded ( and written) by the excellent band Badfinger in 1970 before Nilsson recorded it in 1972, both excellent versions. Similarly "Everybody's talkin' at me" was previously a hit for another artist ( sorry forgot his name) in the mid 1960s. Nilsson wrote a so g for Midnight Cowboy that was t used that's a belter called "I guess the Lord must be in New York city"

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3Dr8cJ1I19cbw&ved=2ahUKEwiLht3QksuWAxVwUUEAHQx2PFUQo7QBegQIFRAF&usg=AOvVaw1ZzWJIfZEoS7oqCajnhvg9

Steve W. said...

MP, when I went to bed, there was a thunderstorm blasting away. So, I decided not to set my alarm to see the lunar eclipse, as it was a safe bet it wouldn't be visible.

Matthew McKinnon said...

My favourite Nilsson song is ‘All I Think About Is You’ - it’s a heartbreaker.